Why Are My Bush Beans Growing Runners?

Question: Hello! I ordered green beans twice…provider beans. I planted my first ones and was worried they weren’t going to grow due to getting an unseasoned late frost after planting. I ordered the exact same beans and planted seeds in spots that ended up not growing in. All of the second package of seeds I planted are vining and appear much different than the first package that I planted. 

Would you have any idea what kind of green beans the second one would be? You can see the plant itself is different. I want to pick them correctly. They have taken over my bean area and are definitely much different of a grower.

Any thoughts would be appreciated. Thanks!

Discover Why Gardeners Recommend Our Seeds!

Bush Beans Growing Runners: What’s Going On?

Answer: Thank you for your email. The vining you mention is just short runners, which can be common among bush beans. This is a known occurrence with bush beans growing runners, and it’s often triggered by environmental conditions. The difference between your two plantings is likely due to changes in weather and soil conditions at the time of the second planting.

In addition to the runner growth, it appears your plants are also showing signs of Brown Spot, a common fungal disease in beans caused by Pseudomonas syringae pv. syringae. The yellowing and browning between leaf veins, along with the reddish-brown speckling and irregular blotches visible in the photo, are classic symptoms. Brown Spot tends to develop in warm, humid conditions and can spread rapidly through splashing rain or overhead watering. While it rarely kills plants outright, it can reduce yields and weaken plant vigor.

To manage it, avoid working among wet plants, remove severely infected leaves, and consider applying a copper-based fungicide if the disease progresses. Going forward, rotate your bean crops each year and avoid planting in the same spot to reduce spore buildup in the soil.

Environmental Factors Behind Bush Beans Growing Runners

The short runners you’re seeing on your second planting of bush beans are likely due to a combination of factors related to the changing environmental conditions between your first and second planting. Many gardeners notice bush beans growing runners when the weather heats up or moisture levels fluctuate.

Genetics and Environmental Influence

While you’ve planted the same variety, it’s important to know that many “bush” bean varieties are actually “half-runner” types. This means they have a natural bush growth habit but are also genetically predisposed to sending out short, sprawling runners or vines, especially under certain conditions. They aren’t as aggressive as true pole beans, but they will still vine out a bit. The first planting may have had ideal conditions that suppressed this trait, while the second planting experienced conditions that encouraged bush beans growing runners.

Temperature and Stress

Bean plants, like all plants, are highly sensitive to their environment. The most significant factor is likely the difference in temperature and moisture between the two planting times. These changes can often lead to bush beans growing runners as a stress response.

Hot Weather

Your second planting is likely experiencing warmer temperatures. High heat (above 90°F or around 32°C) can be stressful for bean plants. In response to this stress, some plants may divert energy into growing runners in an attempt to find more favorable conditions, such as shadier, moister soil, or to spread out and increase their chances of survival. This is a common reason for bush beans growing runners unexpectedly.

Watering

Consistent soil moisture is crucial for beans. If your second planting is receiving less consistent water, or if the soil is drying out more quickly due to the hotter weather, this water stress can also trigger the plant to produce runners. The plant’s goal is to keep growing and producing, and if the main stem is struggling, it will try to send out new growth to find resources. This too can result in bush beans growing runners.

Soil and Nutrients

The soil and nutrient availability can also play a role in the behavior of bush beans growing runners.

Nitrogen

Beans are legumes and can “fix” nitrogen from the atmosphere, but they still require a balanced diet of other nutrients. Too much nitrogen can cause excessive foliage and vine growth at the expense of flowering and pod production. If your second planting is in soil that is richer in nitrogen for some reason (e.g., you added a high-nitrogen fertilizer or it’s a new bed), this could be contributing to your bush beans growing runners.

Soil Compaction

If the soil in the second bed is more compacted, the plants may be sending out runners in a search for looser soil to establish roots. This soil stress can be another factor in bush beans growing runners more than expected.

Day Length

While bush beans are generally “day-neutral” (meaning their flowering isn’t impacted by day length), the change in the amount of daylight hours can still affect a plant’s overall growth patterns. As the season progresses, the change in light may play a minor role in how the plant allocates its energy, potentially encouraging runner development. This subtle shift can lead to bush beans growing runners later in the season.

Conclusion: Why Bush Beans Are Growing Runners

In summary, the most probable cause is a combination of your bean variety’s genetic predisposition to half-runner growth and the warmer, potentially drier conditions of your second planting. The plants are essentially reacting to environmental stress by putting energy into growing runners as a survival mechanism. So if you see bush beans growing runners, it’s usually nothing to worry about—just their natural way of adjusting to changing conditions.

FAQ: